Author Topic: digital or traditional art? your thoughts!  (Read 1220 times)

FrostyxxFreeze

  • Lurker
  • Posts: 2
    • View Profile
digital or traditional art? your thoughts!
« on: February 15, 2010, 06:21:09 AM »
So ive wondered for a while now what people honestly like more digital or traditional art? As a traditional artist i find that when im buying art i like to buy traditional art because it shows the time and detail someone has truly put into it. I also feel as though people appreciate it more due to that fact but plz let me know im really curious?

Archimer

  • Staff Department Head
  • Forum Ninja
  • *****
  • Posts: 491
  • Today's Tom Sawyer
    • View Profile
    • WaffleHaus
Re: digital or traditional art? your thoughts!
« Reply #1 on: February 15, 2010, 09:50:36 AM »
Hahah, it never fails; this argument comes up at least once a year on these forums. :) I should start betting money on it!

I work with both "digital" and "traditional" means. I like painting and drawing, and I like digital painting and vector art. These two realms of art are very closely related, if not absolutely parallel. I would argue that there is no difference in skill level with traditional art versus digital art. Digital art tools like painting programs and tablets will not help a bad artist make good work. The fabled computer "art button" does not exist. ;)

- Arch
:arch:
Attendee 03 / Art Staff 04 / Art Chair 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13
Arch @ (Home)(Last.fm)(tumblr)

JERKS!

animedevildog

  • Forum Geek
  • ****
  • Posts: 657
  • Official PortCon Biker
    • View Profile
    • My Fanfic profile
Re: digital or traditional art? your thoughts!
« Reply #2 on: February 15, 2010, 10:04:20 PM »
Arch, I will NOT take you up on that bet...

For me, it doesn't really matter much. I have seen examples of both traditional and digital that were outstanding. Art is art, and digital is just one more variety for us to enjoy.
PortConMaine Boardgames staff 2k8, 2k9. General Staff 2k10
Killin pixilated zombies with pixilated machine guns...

FrostyxxFreeze

  • Lurker
  • Posts: 2
    • View Profile
Re: digital or traditional art? your thoughts!
« Reply #3 on: February 17, 2010, 11:44:45 AM »
i see where u both are coming from and i appreciate the feedback

Moritani

  • Staff
  • Forum Ninja
  • *****
  • Posts: 284
    • View Profile
Re: digital or traditional art? your thoughts!
« Reply #4 on: February 17, 2010, 09:04:45 PM »
Well, if I may state my personal opinion, I find that while both are difficult, the terms used are far too broad.

"Digital" art I usually think of as Photoshop/AI/Maya and whatnot, but some think that poser is "art" (which, I would have to disagree with.)

"Traditional" art can very greatly from sculpture to painting to doodles on notebooks to whatever the heck Dadaists did.

So, as for which requires more skill you would need to define the exact mediums. I assume you're referring to flat imagery, so I'll ignore Maya and sculpture for now. Basically, it is easier to get amateur flashy imagery out of a digital work than a traditional one due to all the shortcuts and tricks. But, sketching on paper is pretty easy, too. Mastering the arts is the hard part  and, in my opinion, any professional artist that can do traditional can do digital. And, usually vice-versa. (though there are exceptions)

Composition, color work, lighting, anatomy, line work, confidence and a scientific understanding of art are the core of an artist's repertoire. Medium is all preference.

After all, Michelangelo hated painting, but look at the Sistine Chapel! I'm sure he could've done that with Paint Tool SAI if he wanted to. (And if they had computers in Renaissance Italy)

atemulover

  • Guest
Re: digital or traditional art? your thoughts!
« Reply #5 on: February 18, 2010, 09:10:15 AM »
Personally I don't make digital art. I'm 100% traditional. I only use a computer for minor touch ups when scanning and putting things on my deviantart account. While things do look badass as digital work, if your doing anime and manga, back in the day, and well still today..everything is made tradtionally (or at least at first). considering the theme for this year is "old skool" it should be easy to sell well done traditional works. Of course you can also show a few digitals on hand just in case too.

Acerotaa

  • Staff
  • Forum Ninja
  • *****
  • Posts: 108
  • ... He too had the king's coin >.>
    • View Profile
Re: digital or traditional art? your thoughts!
« Reply #6 on: February 19, 2010, 09:40:06 PM »
I agree with Archimer, and I only rarely do a purely digital piece of artwork, and usually it is either a map (or 3-d model) or a free form drawing (i.e. weeeeeeeeeeeee photoshop). This is mostly due to the crappy mac trackpads and my lazyness in not getting a tablet... but, i think that they are both great mediums, and, as for any other medium, have their own share of hacks and people who think they are great (but arn't)
Tech Ops 2011




Dodrio

  • Forum Ninja
  • ***
  • Posts: 110
  • SRSLY
    • View Profile
    • Dodrio at DeviantART
Re: digital or traditional art? your thoughts!
« Reply #7 on: February 20, 2010, 05:24:15 PM »
I think that both traditional art and digital art require a level of skill that, whether you do one or the other, requires lots of practice and patience to learn how to do it and make a nice piece.
I dabble in both digital and traditional. I find that with digital, a lot of it is memorization. It takes time to learn which function does what and how each component in a program works. And on top of that, you then have to learn how each part can go together to make a cool effect. Like in Photoshop, when drawing anime/manga-styled, some people choose to shade their hair by drawing a line of color and then smudging/blending it, while other people use gradients (and then the rest do all sorts of other things). Both can achieve a cool looking effect. So even though it is on the computer and certain tools are used to do certain things, depending on how you combine them, you can get different effects, much like traditional art. Different tools can used to create different effects, but most people figure these out from tutorials, experimenting, etc.
When creating a white spot in an eye or a shiny part of an outfit or something, some people dab white paint or use white-out or a white gel-pen. Other people just leave the paper white and are super sure to just draw/color around it. Traditional art is much like digital art in this way that it is all about technique. It takes awhile to learn, takes experimentation, directions, etc.
In that sense, both take a relatively equal amount of skill and practice to learn to create good images. It takes a long time to get good with Prismacolor pencils as it does to get good making vectors.

But in a different context, drawing itself is totally different. If you cannot draw a person with correct proportions on paper, chances are, you cannot do it on a computer. Having a fancy-dandy program will not give you the ability to do something that you yourself do not know. People who do strictly digital drawings, that's all fine and cool. But they too had to learn the basics of proportion, shading, design, etc. It just takes a different skill to learn to recreate it on Photoshop than it takes to do it with colored pencils.
Lots of artists who aren't exactly amazing who work with digital art complain that their images aren't good because they don't have Photoshop/Illustrator/Whatever. For the most part, that's not true. Like Arch said, there's no magic "Art Button".

But this is all in relation to 2D drawings, paintings, etc. As far as sculptures and 3D art goes with Blender and such, I've got no idea how those compare to each other. But I figure it's roughly the same idea. If you don't know the basics and how-to behind it, I don't think you can recreate it digitally (or traditionally).

I feel like I strayed from the main topic. xD Overall, I like both traditional art and digital art equally. I just like what looks pretty... and preferably didn't use a template (digital 'artists', I'm thinking of you >>;; )
« Last Edit: February 20, 2010, 05:26:17 PM by Dodrio »

No, you.

NEEEEEEEEER

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 20
    • View Profile
Re: digital or traditional art? your thoughts!
« Reply #8 on: February 23, 2010, 10:30:39 PM »
Hmm...tough question...Ill be honest Traditional I find more attractive, and would be more willing to buy. I mean they both require a lot of strenuous work no doubt about that (digital artist) but I would go with traditional than again this is only one persons opinion...from what I know im far to lazy to read other peoples responses.....XD

fox inuzuka

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 42
  • One zombie down...Well one down
    • View Profile
Re: digital or traditional art? your thoughts!
« Reply #9 on: February 24, 2010, 03:37:57 AM »
Traditional hands down becuase your right it shows the time and care they put into making there ebautiful work of art and it shows the dedication and determination of an artist more over i would say
Buttseck ninja 07,08 09
Digi Camo Soldier 09
Rave kid 07, 08, 09

RhymeNKyo~

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 10
  • I live to Con~
    • View Profile
Re: digital or traditional art? your thoughts!
« Reply #10 on: April 13, 2010, 02:22:36 PM »
This trimester in school I'm taking graphic design which works with photoshop and it's not as easy as one might think. Given nor is traditional...

When it comes to where I stand I love both types of arts equally. Traditional looks so beautiful and made with lots of effort and Digital looks so crisp, like something I could buy from an anime store.

However I agree with atemulover... The theme is old skool so I'd like to see more traditional art
Working on a Ty Lee Cosplay for this year... Any advice? PM me~ ^^

aysiel

  • Staff
  • Forum Ninja
  • *****
  • Posts: 209
  • meow
    • View Profile
    • tumblr
Re: digital or traditional art? your thoughts!
« Reply #11 on: April 14, 2010, 12:03:36 PM »
Personally, when it comes to sketches and linearts, I like to stay with traditional media. I have a habit of turning my paper around whenever I need something to be at a certain angle, and that doesn't really work when I'm on Photoshop.

As for coloring, I do it digitally. I can easily fix my mistakes, and it's clean. I'm currently in a vocational art class where the teacher is helping me with digital painting.

I guess it really depends on what you prefer
2008-11
2012-13: Registration Staff
PCM 2013: Malik Al-Sayf [Assassin's Creed], Sherlock Holmes [BBC Sherlock], Zacharie [OFF], Will Graham [NBC Hannibal]

Archimer

  • Staff Department Head
  • Forum Ninja
  • *****
  • Posts: 491
  • Today's Tom Sawyer
    • View Profile
    • WaffleHaus
Re: digital or traditional art? your thoughts!
« Reply #12 on: April 14, 2010, 07:09:38 PM »
High five, fellow paper-turner!

RhymeNKyo: You're taking a graphic design class that uses Photoshop? Kick your teacher and tell them to show you some Illustrator before the semester's out! ;)
Attendee 03 / Art Staff 04 / Art Chair 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13
Arch @ (Home)(Last.fm)(tumblr)

JERKS!

atemulover

  • Guest
Re: digital or traditional art? your thoughts!
« Reply #13 on: April 24, 2010, 12:48:44 AM »
So ive wondered for a while now what people honestly like more digital or traditional art? As a traditional artist i find that when im buying art i like to buy traditional art because it shows the time and detail someone has truly put into it. I also feel as though people appreciate it more due to that fact but plz let me know im really curious?

well I'm a traditional artist who has recently been switching to digital color versus just traditional. I do say, digital color almost always comes out better and brighter with ease while traditional art seems to be a bit dull... due to the fact that traditional art is probably 1000% harder to do than digital coloring since there is no erasing or brighten/contrast, sharpens or blur buttons to help you out. that is unless you are seriously gifted in traditional art and can make a carbon copy of the digital print. also digital seems to look more professional. Although it's also cool to do something traditional and add digital to it. I guess it just depends really (most of the time though people buy digital though)

okapirose

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 15
    • View Profile
    • CL'ay La Vie-Cat
Re: digital or traditional art? your thoughts!
« Reply #14 on: April 24, 2010, 12:38:14 PM »
This always comes up and my answer for the question ahs probably already been said but...

Neither and both. Its not the medium, its how you use it and which you feel more comfortable with.